The return to the office is causing numerous employment disputes, as some companies are cutting remote working days while others are going back to a fully office-based model.
This raises a key question: can a company withdraw remote working and require the employee to return to the office?
The answer depends on how remote working was set up. Exercising a validly agreed reversibility clause is not the same as unilaterally changing the agreed percentage of remote work.
Remote working is voluntary for both parties
Spain’s Remote Working Act (Law 10/2021) provides that remote working is voluntary for both the company and the employee.
As a general rule, it requires a signed remote working agreement, which can be included in the initial contract or formalised later.
Among other things, this agreement must set out:
- The percentage of on-site and remote work.
- How working time is distributed.
- The place chosen for remote work.
- The duration of the agreement.
- The equipment provided by the company.
- The mechanisms for monitoring the work.
- The deadlines and conditions for exercising reversibility.
- The procedure to follow in the event of technical problems.
Remote working conditions should therefore not depend solely on a generic internal policy, but must be properly documented.
Reversibility and modification are not the same thing
One of the main contributions of recent case law is the distinction between two situations:
Fully reversing remote working
Reversibility means returning to the previous on-site model.
It can be exercised on the terms set out in:
- The applicable collective agreement.
- The individual remote working agreement.
- The remote working policy validly incorporated into the agreement.
If the collective or individual agreement allows the company to request a return to the office and sets a notice period, the reversal may be valid provided those conditions are respected and it is not exercised in an abusive or discriminatory way or in breach of fundamental rights.
Changing the percentage of remote work
A different situation arises when the company does not remove remote working entirely, but reduces the agreed days.
For example:
- Going from five remote days to three.
- Cutting remote work from 80% to 50%.
- Adding new mandatory office days.
- Unilaterally changing the agreed weekly schedule.
Article 8 of Law 10/2021 provides that any change to the conditions set out in the agreement, including the percentage of on-site work, must be agreed between the company and the employee and put in writing.
The company cannot unilaterally reduce remote working days
The Supreme Court has ruled that a company cannot unilaterally change the percentage of remote work set out in individual agreements.
In the case examined, the company reduced the remote work granted to certain employees with disabilities from 100% to 75%. The Court concluded that the change breached Law 10/2021 as regards those who had not individually accepted it.
The Court made clear that:
- The percentage of remote work forms part of the individual agreement.
- Changing it requires the consent of both parties.
- A company decision is not enough.
- Individual consent cannot be replaced by a collective agreement.
- The company cannot impose the change through the substantial modification procedure under Article 41 of the Workers’ Statute.
Even where there are organisational reasons, the company therefore cannot limit agreed remote working without the consent of the person concerned.
What if the agreement contains a reversibility clause?
The law allows the collective agreement or the individual agreement to regulate the return to on-site work.
The Supreme Court has upheld certain clauses that allow:
- Reversal with a notice period.
- A temporary return due to information security issues.
- On-site work when it is materially impossible to work remotely.
- A return in the event of certain technical or health and safety incidents.
However, the clause must be clear and comply with the collective agreement. Its application may also be challenged in court if it is abusive or does not match the circumstances provided for.
A generic clause should not be understood as unlimited permission to change the conditions whenever the company sees fit.
What happens if the contract was remote from the start?
The situation may be different when the person was hired from the outset to work fully remotely.
The law refers expressly to the reversibility of the decision to move from an on-site model to a remote one. When the employment relationship began as remote, it cannot always be said that there is a previous on-site situation to return to.
In these cases, the following will need to be examined:
- The wording of the contract.
- The remote working agreement.
- Whether there is an assigned workplace.
- The collective agreement.
- Any on-site attendance or mobility clauses.
- The specific circumstances of the hiring.
If remote work was an essential condition for accepting the job, later imposing on-site work may be particularly contentious.
Remote working granted for family reasons
Ordinarily agreed remote work must also be distinguished from remote work granted as a work-life balance measure.
Article 34.8 of the Workers’ Statute allows employees to request adjustments to the length and distribution of working time, including remote work, to exercise their right to balance family and working life.
When remote working is granted on this basis, its withdrawal must be assessed taking into account:
- The agreed duration.
- The family reason that justified the request.
- The company’s organisational needs.
- The negotiation procedure followed.
- Whether circumstances have changed significantly.
- The proportionality of the measure.
The company should not automatically withdraw a working time adjustment without negotiating and properly justifying its decision.
Can someone who refuses to return be dismissed?
Merely refusing to accept a unilateral change to the percentage of remote work is not automatically valid grounds for dismissal.
Law 10/2021 provides that the following cannot justify terminating the employment relationship:
- The employee’s refusal to switch to remote work.
- Exercising reversibility to return to on-site work.
- Difficulties linked solely to the change from on-site to remote work.
However, if the company correctly exercises a reversibility clause provided for in the collective or individual agreement and the return instruction is valid, a persistent and unjustified refusal could lead to disciplinary measures.
Before taking disciplinary action, the company must check that the instruction:
- Is covered by the applicable agreement.
- Has been properly communicated.
- Respects the notice period.
- Does not infringe work-life balance rights.
- Is not discriminatory.
- Is not a reprisal.
- Can actually be complied with.
What can an employee do if they disagree?
When instructed to return to the office, it is advisable to request in writing:
- The reason for the decision.
- The contractual or collective agreement clause that supports it.
- The effective date.
- The on-site attendance schedule.
- The specific conditions of the return.
- Confirmation of whether the measure is temporary or permanent.
The employee can challenge the decision in court if they consider that it contradicts their agreement, infringes their work-life balance rights or conceals discriminatory conduct.
It is important to act quickly, as certain employment proceedings are subject to short deadlines.
What should companies review?
Before introducing a return-to-office policy, it is advisable to review:
- Individual contracts and remote working agreements.
- Reversibility clauses.
- The applicable collective agreements.
- The agreed on-site percentages.
- Adjustments granted for work-life balance.
- Commitments made during hiring.
- The situation of employees with disabilities.
- Notice periods.
- The need to reach individual agreements.
- The risks of indirect discrimination.
A general announcement to all staff may not be enough if each employee has signed an agreement with different conditions.
The importance of a well-drafted remote working agreement
Disputes about returning to the office usually stem from incomplete agreements or ambiguous clauses.
Proper regulation should clearly distinguish between:
- Full reversibility.
- Temporary changes.
- Changes to the percentage of remote work.
- Grounds for an immediate return.
- The notice period.
- The communication procedure.
- Work-life balance situations.
- The consequences of technical incidents.
At Abansa we advise companies and employees on drafting and reviewing remote working agreements, return-to-office policies, work-life balance and changes to working conditions.